Loyalty tax: 2023’s top employee retention risk

a group of coworkers smiling at the camera
Published: 24 Jan, 2023
High salary offers made to new staff in 2022 are now fuelling pay equity concerns for tenured employees, who could pay a price for their loyalty.
According to the last Hays Salary Guide, 63% of 4,800 professionals surveyed said they’d benefit financially from changing jobs.
“Skills shortages drove up salary offers for many new starters in 2022,” says Adam Shapley, Managing Director of Hays in New Zealand.
“For skills in highest demand, employers offered a salary increase up to CPI to secure a candidate. This exceeded average salary increases for existing staff, financially penalising loyal employees who are acutely aware of the monetary benefit of changing jobs.”
Hays also notes a small increase in the number of employers offering a sign-on bonus. According to a LinkedIn poll Hays ran in late 2022, 8% of 18,045 professionals surveyed said they’d received a starting bonus in the past six months. 

Tips for employees: Ask for a pay rise

If you suspect your salary is lower than a new starter’s pay, Hays suggests you:
  • Research typical salaries: Consult salary guides and job advertisements for similar roles to compare your pay. Try to remain objective. For instance, does the new hire possess different expertise to you? If so, research salaries for the most accurate skills. 
  • Collate your achievements: Gather examples of your recent work that exceed expectations, additional duties undertaken and achievements you’re proud of. The aim here is to present clear evidence of your value.
  • Meet with your boss: Book a meeting with your manager to explain your concerns. Mention that you feel underpaid and present your research and achievements. Then state how much you believe your efforts are worth. Ask if your boss can audit your salary externally and internally and review your pay.
  • Have a reserve standpoint: Pay discrepancies can occur when a new employee negotiates a higher starting salary. If your employer can’t increase your salary at this point, use your own negotiation skills to improve your non-financial benefits. For instance, additional annual leave, a promotional pathway or upskilling could help close the gap. 

Tips for employers: Revise pay inequalities

Any pay discrepancy between new and tenured employees can impact employee engagement, productivity and turnover – unless you address it quickly. Hays suggests you:
  • Benchmark salaries: Compare external and new starter salaries with all employees’ wages. Are they consistent? If any salaries have fallen out of sync with market trends and new starters, can you offer an immediate raise? If not, what else can you offer to bridge the gap to retain your best talent? 
  • Add a buffer to the salary budget: Salary budgets are expected to increase by around 3% in 2023. If possible, factor additional salary adjustments into your budget to ensure your salaries remain fair for all to retain your top performers. 
  • Be transparent: Can you publicly disclose the salary when recruiting for a new role? If not, ensure the starting salary is justifiable in the context of similar positions within the team, and share the data, formula or rationale used to calculate pay levels so employees understand your approach.
  • Consider non-financial benefits: If your budget doesn’t allow you to increase salaries for tenured staff, consider what else you can offer to reward their loyalty. For instance, can you provide them with additional annual leave, more flexibility or time for upskilling? 
- Ends -
For further information please contact Kathryn Crowden at kathryn.crowden@hays.com.au or Clare Zacka at clare.zacka@hays.com.au.

press release about us

About Hays

Hays is the leading specialist in recruitment and workforce solutions.

Hays is the most followed recruitment agency on LinkedIn. Follow Hays and join our growing network.
twitter_social_media_online_share.png Get expert advice, insights and the latest recruitment news by following us @HaysNewZealand